Categories
Web/Tech

Should You Buy A Solid State Drive?

If you want to improve the performance of your modern (SATA II) laptop, consider replacing the mechanical hard drive with a solid state drive (SSD). Unlike a regular hard disk drive (HDD), an SSD is very rugged and has no moving parts. Other benefits: reduced power usage, reduced noise and reduced heat generation. And Buy.com has rebates through 18 June 2010.

Article contents

Moreover, with modern processors, productivity can be increased dramatically by reducing the read/write time by a factor of 2-4 times and access time as much two orders of magnitude:

The fastest consumer hard drives take 7 milliseconds to read data off of a platter. The fastest consumer CPUs can do something with that data in one hundred thousandth that time. (source)

Here’s an in-work table of solid state drives (how they work) and benchmark data that I’ve found from reviews. I pulled this data together to help me decide which drive to buy; maybe it will help you, too!

Note: as of this writing, only Windows 7 has TRIM support for data management (no other Windows OS and no Mac OS). One of the reasons I’m trying the Kingston 80 is this review of the Kingston 30:

And if you’re running an OS without TRIM support, Kingston’s drive appears to be the most resilient of the bunch.

Drive Sequential Read/Write Pros-Cons Price
HDD For Benchmarking
Hitachi Travelstar 7K500
HTS725050A9A364, 7200 rpm, 500GB
Test:
82.7 MBps
, read average; 83 MBps, write average; Read Access, 15.9 ms
3-year warranty $95.99-OWC
$78.09-Amazon
Western Digital Scorpio Blue
WD7500BPVT, 5400 rpm, 750GB
Test:
74.1 MBps, read average; 73.1 MBps, write average; Read Access, 16.2 ms
3-year warranty $199.99-Amazon
Indilinx Controller
OCZ Agility EX /64GB OCZSSD2-1AGTEX60G Spec: 255/195 MBps

Test:
246/234 MBps w/EVEREST

3-year warranty

Only 64GB
No USB Mini-B
Needs converter
2009 model

$161.99-Amazon
Intel Controller
Intel X25-M / 80GB
SSDSA2M080G2
Spec: 250/70 MBps

Test:
256.9/81.6 MBps;
Read Access, 0.1 ms

TRIM support; 3-year warranty

Introduced in 2009, but firmware updates have addressed performance issues

$219.99-NewEgg
$219.99-ZipZoomFly
$224.99-Amazon
Samsung Controller
Corsair Performance
CMFSSD-64GBG2D
Spec: 220/120 MBps TRIM support;
3-year warranty; 128MB of cache memory

No public firmware updates

$174.99-Buy.Com
(+$30 rebate thru 6/30)
Kingston SSDNow V+
SNV225-S2/64GB
Spec: 220/140 MBps

Test:
241/150 MBps w/EVEREST

TRIM support;
3-year warranty

No public firmware updates
No USB Mini-B
2009 model

Many OEM Drives No public firmware updates
Sandforce Controller
Corsair Force F100 Test:
284/277 MBps w/ATTO
TRIM support

No public firmware updates
No USB Mini-B
Only 2-year warranty

OCZ Vertex-2/100GB
OCZSSD2-2VTX100G
Test:
233/235 MBps w/ATTO
93.1GB accessible
TRIM support
3-year warranty
$353.99-Buy.com
(+ $30 rebate thru 6/18)
$360.50-Amazon
OWC Mercury Extreme Pro RE
OWCSSDMXRE100/100GB
Test:
286/276 MBps w/ATTO
TRIM, SMART, and RAISE support; 5-year warranty

No USB Mini-B

$399.99-OWC
Patriot Inferno – PI100GS25SSDR/100GB Test:
286/277 MBps w/ATTO
TRIM, SMART, and RAISE support; 5-year warranty

No public firmware updates
No USB Mini-B

$369-NewEgg
$407.99-Amazon
Toshiba Controller
Kingston SSDNow V
SNV425-S2BN/128GB
Spec: 200/110 MBps
Test:
214/190 MBps w/AS SSD
Notebook bundle includes cloning software;
TRIM, SMART support; Second Gen

119GB accessible on 128GB drive

64GB drive: $159-NewEgg
$147.83-Amazon
$144.95-Buy.com
(+$35 rebate thru 6/18)

128GB drive:
$258.99-Amazon

Kingston SSDNow V+ G2 SNVP325-S2/128GB Spec: 230/180 MBps

Test:
238/188MBps w/ATTO

TRIM support; 3-year warranty

No public firmware updates
No USB Mini-B

$329-NewEgg
$315.15-Amazon

Sources:

:: Follow Me On Twitter!
:: WiredPen Permalink

By Kathy E. Gill

Digital evangelist, speaker, writer, educator. Transplanted Southerner; teach newbies to ride motorcycles! @kegill

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.