Advocating media critique

Yesterday, the Department hosted Robert Jensen, associate professor at the University of Texas – Austin, for a conversation about media, war and politics. He is promoting a new book, Citizens of the Empire: The Struggle to Claim our Humanity. I found the title intriguing, given former Sen. Gary Hart’s admonition yesterday that election 2004 will signal whether America wishes to be an empire or a republic.

Jensen suggested that there are three criteria to evaluate when organizing a critique of media coverage — coverage which should provide information that citizens need to actively participate in civic matters:

  1. Provide an independent source of factual information
  2. Provide historical and political context
  3. Expose citizens to the widest possible range of information

Continue reading

Kerry, the day after

These days, it’s rare that I have the opportunity to attend a newsworthy event and then read about it afterward, contrasting my experience with the ‘reported’ facts. So I relished the opportunity to see how the Kerry speech was reported, both locally and nationally.

Locally, the most obvious was positioning in the printed paper. The Seattle P-I placed the story above the fold, with full-width headline. The Seattle Times placed the story below the fold, in the right column; they placed far more emphasis on a Microsoft campus being built in India. Web site placement and column inches continued that trend. I have to re-think my subscription to The Times.

“Attack” charged
If I failed to mention it yesterday, I found Kerry’s tone and words to be extremely measured. He didn’t (proverbially) froth at the mouth. His dispatchment of Administration shortcomings was, in my view, indirect. He mentioned the Bush Administration by name once; he mentioned the President by name once.
Continue reading

Kerry lays out security strategy – 2

Commentary
My first impression was of height. There was the veteran who led the Pledge, Hart and Kerry — lined up on stage in ascending order. Kerry towered over both men. As a colleague in the Department says, this could prove advantageous in the debates — if we are allowed to see the difference. I have doubts.

He was articulate; he’s not as stiff as Al Gore (thank goodness). His face lights up when he shares a genuine smile — as when he broke into a grin when seeing someone in the audience (former Sen. Max Cleland (D-GA)?). We need to see that face more often, instead of the poker-faced, measured persona more often on view.
Continue reading

Kerry lays out security strategy – 1

Mid-morning today in Seattle, Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) laid out a four-point strategy designed to create a “secure” America. This is the first in a series of policy speeches planned from now until D-Day, June 6.

The speech comes on the eve of the dedication of the WWII Memorial in Washington, DC, an event which will provide incumbent President Bush with an opportunity to wrap his administration policies in the flag.

Former Sen. Gary Hart (D-CO) set the context in his introduction when he asserted that this election will demonstrate if America wishes to be a “republic or empire.”
Continue reading